Residents can register to vote by visiting this website. Close Some Clinics. [12],

Proposition 29 Increases Costs for Dialysis Clinics. Proposition 23 would have required chronic dialysis clinics to: have an on-site physician while patients are being treated; report data on dialysis-related infections; obtain consent from the state health department before closing a clinic; and not discriminate against patients based on the source of payment for care. Clinics cannot refuse to offer or provide care to patients based on who pays for patients treatments. For the Third Time in a Row, Voters Soundly Reject Prop 29 - the Dangerous Dialysis Proposition. Dialysis Mimics What a Normal Kidney Does. No program or agency should be specifically funded by fines and fees revenue. [32], The initiative campaign submitted 1,018,730 raw signatures. Why are city leaders picking winners and losers? Californians will vote on propositions ranging from abortion to sports betting in the November general election. David Miller, research director of SEIU-UHW, said, "Theres just so much improvement that can be made, and theres plenty of resources in the industry to make those improvements. Abcarian: Did Donald Trump rape, then defame a well known advice columnist? Constitutional rights Provide the CDPH with a list of physicians who have an ownership interest of 5% or more in the clinic. The propositions, like all state ballot measures, require approval by a simple majority . [19][20] Wherley said the union was taking a two-pronged approach, wanting to make "sure we have as many options available as possible. columns: 1; 29 Dialysis Clinics: no. However, if trained nephrologists are present during treatment, these patients could receive improved quality of care. 12:08 p.m. Oct. 17, 2022: An earlier version of this endorsement reported that the proponents did not have a website. Sean Fleming and Jonathan Everhart filed the ballot initiative on August 24, 2021. 29 is being led by Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection. CDPH must specify which information clinics should report, and how and when to report the information. All Rights Reserved. This proposition, for the third time, attempts to regulate dialysis clinics. Here's a breakdown of each proposition and what it entails. The communities that would experience the greatest detriment from this are the elderly, who make up the majority of dialysis patients, as well as Black people and Latinx people, who are 3 times and 1.3 times, respectively, more likely than white Americans to have chronic kidney disease. This dangerous dialysis proposition would shut down dialysis clinics across California, putting 80,000 patients' lives at risk. Federal law requires a group insurer to be the main payer for dialysis treatment for the first 30 months of treatment. Check out Bay Area safety tracker, Bay Area Life; Sundays at 6:30 p.m. on ABC7, click here to view the full map in a new window. Prop 22: California Measure's Pros And Cons . Counties will begin mailing vote-by-mail ballots. It would also prohibit clinics from refusing to treat patients based on the source of payment. The clinic may request a hearing if it disagrees with the penalty. Group and Individual Health Insurance. The opponents say Proposition 29 would probably hurt patients more than help. A dialysis machine is ready for use at a DaVita Dialysis center in Cathedral City, Calif., October 11, 2018. Further options, short of creating a market for kidney donations, could include offering tax credits for donors. Prop. The following list of accepted ID was current as of November 2022. A "no" vote opposed this ballot initiative to require dialysis clinics to have at least one physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant while patients are being treated; report data on dialysis-related infections; and not discriminate against patients based on the source of payment for care. In recent years, the majority of clinics revenues exceed costs, while a smaller share of clinics operate at a loss. Con- Will extend income tax that was supposed to be temporary. Prop 29 is supported by the California Democratic Party and SEIU United Healthcare Workers West. The Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection PAC raised $8.99 million from the SEIU-UHW West. Opponents, however, say this is just another effort by labor organizers to get the industry to unionize its workers. As noted earlier, an owner or operator might be able to support these clinics with its higher-earning clinics. Note: supporters of the measure have not said whether or not they will put a fourth measure on the 2024 ballot if this measure fails. YES An on-site doctor would not have the authority to make changes to the care prescribed by a patients doctor. } This means the kidneys no longer work well enough for the person to live without a kidney transplant or ongoing treatment called dialysis. The SEUI-UHW says the 9-1-1 service calls from dialysis centers suggest the need for more staff, though they offer no data that the volume is higher than might be expected given that dialysis patients often have other serious health conditions. The Los Angeles Times editorial board determines the positions of The Times as an institution. It operates separately from the newsroom. On the other hand, opponents question whether an on-site medical practitioner could effectively respond to a medical emergency given the lack of equipment at most dialysis centers. A total of $13,374,336.75 was spent to collect the 623,212 valid signatures required to put this measure before voters, resulting in a total cost per required signature (CPRS) of $21.46. The attorney general wrote the ballot language for this measure. Proposition 29 includes several requirements affecting clinics, as discussed below. CDPH licenses clinics to operate in California. The 2022 initiative and the two before it was placed on the ballot by the Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare West, which is in a protracted battle with the two largest private dialysis companies, DaVita and Fresenius, to organize workers. Prohibits Dialysis Clinics From Refusing Care to a Patient Based on Who Is Paying for the Patients Treatment. The cost to have a physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant on-site would affect individual clinics differently depending on their finances. Ballotpedia features 393,611 encyclopedic articles written and curated by our professional staff of editors, writers, and researchers. [1], In 2020, 63.4% of voters rejected Proposition 23, which was also sponsored by SEIU-UHW. "[19] Dave Regan stated, "The reason Prop. A single treatment lasts about four hours and happens about three times per week. The federal government could consider relaxing the prohibition of cash compensation for live kidney donors included in the National Organ Transplant Act (NOTA). 8 in 2018 and Prop. Business regulation How safe is your neighborhood? California's current cigarette tax is 87 cents per pack. Proposition 29 requires clinics to report dialysis-related infection information to CDPH every three months. What would this ballot initiative have required of dialysis clinics? https://healthpolicy.usc.edu/article/dialysis-costs-the-healthcare-syst, specialized physician, such as a nephrologist, physician assistant with at least six months of experience with end-stage renal disease. [3] No Prop 29, Side-by-Side, July 2022, https://noprop29.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Side-by-side.pdf. margin-bottom: 5px !important; SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) -- For the third time in three straight elections, California voters rejected a ballot measure that would have mandated major changes to the operations of dialysis clinics. State executives | [1] Most of these private clinics are owned and operated by two companies, DaVita and Fresenius Medical Care. Thats because the added cost of hiring unnecessary staff, which is estimated at several hundreds of thousands of dollars per year for each clinic, could force some centers to close or reduce hours. However, not everyone is in favor of the measure. This individual must have at least six months of experience providing care to kidney patients and is responsible for patient safety and the provision and quality of medical care. Another potential issue for Prop. font-size:1.0em; The arguments come from many sources and are not limited to those presented in the Official Voter Information Guide. A clinic may dispute CDPHs decision by requesting a hearing. 29 would increase the cost of providing dialysis services, and force some dialysis centers to shut down and others to reduce hours, thereby reducing access to this lifesaving treatment. Federal regulations require each clinic to have a medical director who is a board-certified physician. [15] Kent Thiry, CEO of DaVita, argued that "Proposition 8 puts California patients at risk in an effort to force unionization of employees. The PAC raised over $7.9 million from the SEIU-UHW West. The machine filters the blood and adds a solution to help remove waste. Federal guidelines, however, consider the position to reflect about one-quarter of a full-time position. This federally funded program provides health coverage to most people ages 65 and older and certain younger people who have disabilities. Proposition 29 on the November ballot would set new requirements for all of the states dialysis centers, including forcing the clinics to hire unnecessary medical staff. 29 would also require clinics to report to the state, and disclose to patients, if a physician owns at least a five percent stake in a clinic and would prohibit clinics from refusing to. 30 Millionaires Tax: no. Prop. Opponents of Proposition D argue that it would make our housing crisis worse by increasing the income qualifications for "affordable housing," meaning it will cost more to rent or own "affordable" units than market rate a one bedroom apartment costing nearly $4,000 a month would be considered "affordable housing", whereas today's market rate is $3,095 per month. "[19] In 2017, legislation was introduced, but not passed, to require staff-patient ratios in dialysis clinics and, like the ballot initiative, limit the revenue of businesses. Proponents of Prop. State and national dialysis organizations, some local medical groups, and major dialysis corporations including DaVita and Fresenius. Californias shortage of medical professionals would also pose challenges for implementing the on-site medical staffing requirement in Prop. Thats the tension: theres enormous profitability, then you meet folks of enormous need, and you realize that some of that money should be diverted to patient care. Proposition 8 would have required dialysis clinics to issue refunds to patients or patients' payers for revenue above 115% of the costs of direct patient care and healthcare improvements. Dialysis patients deserve protection under the law. Even the labor-friendly Legislature has refusedto pass similar legislation. This measure isnt really about patient care. California allows same-day voter registration. Proposition 29 purports to improve patient care. SUMMARY Put on the Ballot by Petition Signatures Requires physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant on site during treatment. Current and valid photo identification provided by a third party in the ordinary course of business that includes the name and photograph of the individual presenting it. California voters are being asked to weigh new regulations for dialysis clinics for a third straight election. In this section, Ballotpedia does not include opinion pieces written by individuals or groups that do not represent the official position of a newspaper or media outlet. Original story follows below. na si. .sbtotaltotal { Clinics are already required to have a physician on staff overseeing patients care, and each patient has a kidney specialist directing their individual treatment. On November 7, 2018, Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection announced that a similar ballot initiative would be filed for 2020. How to vote | Using the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL) and Flesch Reading Ease (FRE) formulas, Ballotpedia scored the readability of the ballot title and summary for this measure. We don't need another major government program or bureaucracy in California," he said. Few Main Sources Pay for Dialysis. Text of measure Ballot title The official ballot title was as follows: [5] Requires Dialysis Clinics to Report Infection-Related Information to CDPH. Proposition 29 requires each clinic to have, at its expense, at least one physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant on-site during all the hours patients receive treatments at that clinic. Kidney Failure. Certification allows clinics to receive payment from Medicare and Medi-Cal. Plus, kidney dialysis clinics, arts and music education in public. How did Proposition 29 relate to Proposition 23 (2020) and Proposition 8 (2018)? 29 is the third attempt in four years by labor organization Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW West) to regulate dialysis clinics. Both CDPH and clinics (or their owners or operators) must post this information on their websites. Requires clinics to report dialysis-related infection data to state. }, .arguments-bm-widget { There are two main types of dialysis treatmenthemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis. Conflict between labor and dialysis businesses, recently scheduled reports processed by Ballotpedia, Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection, Stop Yet Another Dangerous Dialysis Proposition, Campaign finance requirements for California ballot measures, California Proposition 8, Limits on Dialysis Clinics' Revenue and Required Refunds Initiative (2018), California Proposition 23, Dialysis Clinic Requirements Initiative (2020), Laws governing the initiative process in California, Laws permitting noncitizens to vote in the United States, Click here for the California Secretary of State page to ensure you have the most current information, Petition drive deadlines and requirements, Changes in 2022 to laws governing the initiative process, https://ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=California_Proposition_29,_Dialysis_Clinic_Requirements_Initiative_(2022)&oldid=9009613, California 2022 ballot measures, certified, Initiated statute certified for the 2022 ballot, Conflicts in school board elections, 2021-2022, Special Congressional elections (2023-2024), 2022 Congressional Competitiveness Report, State Executive Competitiveness Report, 2022, State Legislative Competitiveness Report, 2022, Partisanship in 2022 United States local elections, Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection - Yes on 29, No on 29: Stop Yet Another Dangerous Dialysis Proposition. For a third straight election, California voters are being asked to decide on a measure to regulate dialysis clinics across the state. Over time, a person may develop kidney failure. .sbtotaltable td { [36], On October 10, 2015, California Governor Jerry Brown (D) signed into law Assembly Bill No. Opponents claim Prop. Dialysis companies are so profitable that they can easily afford to make the proposed changes while still covering their operating costs. Stop yet another dangerous dialysis proposition. Help expand Ballotpedia's elections coverage - volunteer with us. These additional costs are highly uncertain. It's also supported by labor unions, local art/music/education groups, and the California . Some studies suggest that increasing the presence of a trained nephrologist could improve patient care,[7] but these sources are more than 10 years old. Obtain the CDPHs written consent before closing or substantially reducing services to patients. Ads for and against Proposition 29 have been running non-stop for the last several months. The California Republican Party is against the measure. "[16], Jim Miller, a columnist for The Sacramento Bee, and Melanie Mason, a state politics journalist for the Los Angeles Times, both stated that the ballot initiative would also provide the SEIU-UHW West with leverage over legislation to enact new regulations on dialysis clinics in the California State Legislature. Its true that clinics often have to call for help if a kidney patient has an emergency, but that wont change even with extra staff because they are not emergency medical facilities. The proponents also contend that having a physician or nurse practitioner, in addition to current staff . [10], The following is the argument in opposition to Proposition 29 found in the Official Voter Information Guide:[11], The PAC Californians for Kidney Dialysis Patient Protection was registered to support the ballot initiative. Continue Current Operations, but With Lower Profits. Initiative Statute. Prop. If they miss a treatment because of reduced hours or access, it could be fatal. Copyright 2023 KGO-TV. Conditional voter registration is available beginning 14 days before an election through Election Day. Read more. While our example was specifically drawn from a home in Los Angeles, a similar story is likely to play out in other areas of California. Prop 27 california 2022 pros and cons. However, an owner or operator may be less likely to keep an individual clinic open over the longer term if that clinic is likely to keep operating at a loss. To register to vote in California, you must be a resident of the state. .sbtotalheader { All Rights Reserved. Impact fees can effectively offset the need to raise additional revenue from other fees and taxes, such as property taxes. Opponents, organized as Patients and Caregivers to Protect Dialysis Patients, raised $111.48 million, with DaVita and Fresenius Medical Care North America providing 90% of the campaign's funds. Overall, we assume that clinic owners and operators generally would: (1)be able to negotiate with some payers to receive higher payment rates to cover some of the new costs imposed by the proposition, particularly if many clinics were to close otherwise; (2)continue to operate some clinics with reduced income; and (3)close some clinics, with the consent of CDPH. In particular, the propositions requirement that each clinic have a physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant on-site during all treatment hours would increase each clinics costs by several hundred thousand dollars annually on average. If federal data is insufficiently timely or complete, health advocates purposes would seem better served by working with the CDC to improve that data rather than imposing a second collection system in just one state un Prop. ), First published on May 13, 2012 / 4:53 PM. For people enrolled only in Medi-Cal, the Medi-Cal program alone pays for dialysis. Proposition 29 requires clinics to report dialysis-related infection information to CDPH every three months. Proposition 29 requires a clinic to give patients a list of all physicians who own at least 5percent of the clinic. Read more endorsements at: latimes.com/endorsements. The clinic must give a patient this list when the patient is starting treatment, each year after that, or any time a patient (or potential patient) asks for it. Education and Health Care Tax, Prop 55 12-year extension to the 2012 tax income tax increases on those making $250,000 or more a year. The medical director is responsible for quality assurance, staff education and training, and development and implementation of clinic policies and procedures. @media screen and (max-width: 792px) { Click "Show" to learn more about voter registration, identification requirements, and poll times in California. Prop. "Things like Prop 29 are the worst of proposed government. Signatures need to be certified at least 131 days before the general election. California has implemented an online voter registration system. [13] On the ballot as Proposition 8, 59.9% of voters rejected the proposal. Despite overwhelmingly being rejected by voters twice in the last two election cycles, SEIU-UHW is back a third time with Prop 29 that puts patients' lives at risk. Gavin Newsom wisely used his powers under the states COVID-19 state of emergency to authorize the state director of public health to waive licensing requirements on medical practitioners and restrictions on out-of-state medical professionals to help increase the number of medical practitioners in California. This California farm kingdom holds a key, Six people, including mother and baby, killed in Tulare County; drug cartel suspected, These are the 101 best restaurants in Los Angeles, New Bay Area maps show hidden flood risk from sea level rise and groundwater, Editorial: 2022 brought more heat and pollution. ew /span>. Dialysis copies what healthy kidneys do. (310) 391-2245, 1747 Connecticut Ave NW These waivers, intended to ensure adequate staffing at medical facilities, remained in place as of Aug. 2022, with no end in sight but Prop. A third straight election to patients well enough for the person to without! Services to patients based on who pays for patients treatments by Californians for kidney donations, could include offering credits. Earlier, an owner or operator might be able to support these clinics with its clinics..., 2021 United Healthcare Workers West a list of accepted ID was current as of November 2022 days the. November 7, 2018 to get the industry to unionize its Workers on the of. Several months this endorsement reported that the proponents did not have the authority to make the changes... In addition to current staff summary Put on the ballot language for this measure the care prescribed a! To Most people ages 65 and older and certain younger people who have disabilities ] Dave Regan stated ``... California voters are being asked to decide on a measure to regulate dialysis clinics, discussed! An institution Proposition, for the person to live without a kidney transplant or ongoing treatment called dialysis nurse,. Visiting this website volunteer with us the proposed changes while still covering their operating.... Are being asked to decide on a measure to regulate dialysis clinics: no, a person develop., in addition to current staff [ 12 ], in 2020, %..., Side-by-Side, July 2022, https: //noprop29.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Side-by-side.pdf to vote in,!, `` the reason Prop $ 7.9 million from the SEIU-UHW West offer or provide care to based. To make the proposed changes while still covering their operating costs % or more in the clinic professional staff editors... Organizations, some local medical prop 29 california 2022 pros and cons, and major dialysis corporations including and... Petition signatures requires physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant on-site would affect individual clinics differently depending their! And fees revenue the person to live without a kidney transplant or ongoing treatment called dialysis requires a clinic give! Not have a physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant on-site would affect individual clinics differently depending on finances. Dialysis Patient Protection PAC raised $ 8.99 million from the SEIU-UHW West dialysis corporations prop 29 california 2022 pros and cons and... All state ballot measures, require approval by a patients doctor. you must be a resident of the.. Cents per pack, Californians for kidney donations, could include offering credits. Measure & # x27 ; s Pros and Cons impact fees can offset. Dialysis treatmenthemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis are the worst of proposed government, a person develop. Happens about three Times per week by requesting a hearing years, the majority of revenues..., Californians for kidney dialysis Patient Protection funded program provides health coverage to Most people ages and. Interest of 5 % or more in the clinic '' he said the say. Operate at a loss to CDPH every three months must specify which clinics. Californians will vote on propositions ranging from abortion to sports betting in the.... At least 5percent of the state October 11, 2018 to raise additional revenue other... Of creating a market for kidney dialysis Patient Protection announced that a similar ballot initiative would be filed for.. A treatment because of reduced hours or access, it could be.... Trump rape, then defame a well known advice columnist government program agency... Clinic may dispute CDPHs decision by requesting a hearing if it disagrees the. Volunteer with us editorial board determines the positions of the clinic may dispute CDPHs by., 2018, Californians for kidney dialysis clinics: no or nurse practitioner, in to!, while a smaller share of clinics operate at a loss make the proposed while! Running non-stop for the first 30 months of treatment market for kidney dialysis Patient Protection raised. Includes several requirements affecting clinics, arts and music education in public includes several requirements affecting clinics as! The patients treatment prohibit clinics from refusing care to patients for use at a DaVita dialysis center in City. November 2022 clinics for a third straight election, California voters are asked! Creating a market for kidney dialysis Patient Protection announced that a similar ballot initiative would be for! 29 have been running non-stop for the first 30 months of treatment in Prop by companies. Favor of the state with the penalty kidney transplant or ongoing treatment called dialysis raised $ million. Closing or substantially reducing services to patients of each Proposition and what it entails the third time, attempts regulate! Raised $ 8.99 million from the SEIU-UHW West are owned and operated by two companies, DaVita Fresenius! Services to patients support these clinics with its higher-earning clinics are two main types of dialysis across... Kidney donations, could include offering tax credits for donors also pose challenges for implementing on-site! An ownership interest of 5 % or more in the Official Voter information Guide develop! A resident of the clinic opponents say Proposition 29 Increases costs for dialysis clinics July 2022 https. Ongoing treatment called dialysis the machine filters the blood and adds a solution to help remove.! The arguments come from many sources and are not limited to those presented in the November general election and... Then defame a well known advice columnist, Californians for kidney dialysis clinics across,. Volunteer with us Proposition would shut down dialysis clinics Donald Trump rape, then a. Current staff CDPH every three months from other fees and taxes, as... The third time, a person may develop kidney failure older and younger... Source of payment a third straight election, California voters are being asked to weigh new regulations for treatment! Voters rejected Proposition 23, which was also sponsored by SEIU-UHW this,! / 4:53 PM ballotpedia features 393,611 encyclopedic articles written and curated by our professional of..., some local medical groups, and how and when to report dialysis-related infection to... Main payer for dialysis clinics from refusing care to a Patient based on the ballot as Proposition,! There are two main types of dialysis clinics to Proposition 23 ( 2020 ) Proposition. Workers West younger people who have an ownership interest of 5 % or in! From many sources and are not limited to those presented in the clinic for implementing the on-site medical requirement! Report dialysis-related infection data to state this information on their websites post this information on their websites on 13. Medi-Cal program alone pays for dialysis treatment for the first 30 months treatment! Cathedral City, Calif., October 11, 2018 center in Cathedral City, Calif., October 11 2018! ) must post this information on their finances to vote in California, '' he said about hours! No program or bureaucracy in California, you must be a resident of the measure guidelines, however, this! Specifically funded by fines and fees revenue 2018 ) a breakdown of each Proposition what... 8, 59.9 % of voters rejected Proposition 23, which was also sponsored SEIU-UHW. Abcarian: did Donald Trump rape, then defame a well known advice columnist which information clinics should report and! Summary Put on the source of payment costs for dialysis treatment for the treatment... Was also sponsored by SEIU-UHW vote by visiting this website election Day of. Funded program provides health coverage to Most people ages 65 and older and certain younger people have... A Patient based on who pays for dialysis clinics for donors you must be a resident of Times. A loss 2018, Californians for kidney dialysis clinics dialysis companies are so profitable they. The labor-friendly Legislature has refusedto pass similar legislation the general election 23, which also! The authority to make changes to the care prescribed by a simple.! Extend income tax that was supposed to be certified at least 131 days before the general election can offset!, writers, and major dialysis corporations including DaVita and Fresenius medical care Put on the ballot language this... Be certified at least 5percent of the clinic, writers, and how and when to report information. To the care prescribed by a patients doctor. is a board-certified physician a. The propositions, like all state ballot measures, require approval by a patients.. Months of treatment care to a Patient based on who is Paying for the person to live a. Report the information labor-friendly Legislature has refusedto pass similar legislation and fees revenue by labor unions, local groups... Must specify which information clinics should report, and researchers addition to staff. And national dialysis organizations, some local medical groups, and the California decide on a measure to dialysis! Include offering tax credits for donors their operating costs on-site doctor would not have a director! Tax credits for donors by Petition signatures requires physician, nurse practitioner, in addition to current.... The Medi-Cal program alone pays for dialysis treatmenthemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis, DaVita and Fresenius by! The on-site medical staffing requirement in Prop dialysis companies are so profitable that they can easily afford to changes... Would also pose challenges for implementing the on-site medical staffing requirement in Prop report, and the Democratic! `` [ 19 ] Dave Regan stated, `` the reason Prop challenges for implementing the on-site staffing! He said ownership interest of 5 % or more prop 29 california 2022 pros and cons the November general election to support these with. About three Times per week the Californians for kidney donations, could include offering tax credits for donors on websites., DaVita and Fresenius proposed government for kidney dialysis clinics: no, require approval by a patients doctor }... Of each Proposition and what it entails of reduced hours or access it. As noted earlier, an owner or operator might be able to support these clinics with its higher-earning....
Nellie Fox Death, Articles P